Fidelitas

Fidelitas Marketing Review: A Costly Lesson in Hype Over SubstanceIf lighting money on fire while watching your business stall sounds fun, Fidelitas Marketing might be your dream agency. Led by CEO Tyler Sickmeyerwhose confidence far outweighs his resultswe expected expertise and innovation. Instead, we got recycled campaigns, panic, and zero ROI.We came to Fidelitas with nearly two decades of digital marketing experience, hoping for fresh insights on paid social. What we got: a rehash of our old campaignsjust less effective. Their Meta expert had no answers and suggested we simply try the same thing again, but harder. Predictably, that failed.On Google Ads, things somehow got worse. When the campaigns tanked, the team went into meltdown modeno pivot, no ideas, just chaos. By the time we were supposed to scale (per Tyler at SHOT Show), we were busy trying to revive dead campaigns. It felt like watching a squirrel do your taxes: frantic, clueless, and painful.When we pulled the plug to stop the bleeding, Tyler responded with legal threats and demanded full payment for services not rendereddespite us being within cancellation terms. Worse, he contacted one of our long-term vendors to trash-talk us, warning them to get paid upfront. Professionalism? Not even close.And good luck disputing chargesthey only accept wire transfers, conveniently making chargebacks nearly impossible.In summary, heres what we got from Fidelitas:No new ideas or strategic directionNegative ROIUnethical billingLegal threatsReputation damage via unprofessional outreachIf you're searching for honest reviews on Fidelitas or Tyler Sickmeyer, take this as your warning. We paid for expertise and got excuses. There are no guarantees in marketingbut accountability and professionalism should be the minimum. Fidelitas failed on both.